You’ve finished a shoot. A folder full of good photos. Now you have to choose your best photos, and somehow far too many photos have ended up with four stars. Some deserved them when you started. Others got them after you’d been looking for a while. Your idea of four stars may have shifted somewhere in between.
Today I’m introducing Portfolio Selector, a free tool that puts two photos side by side and asks: “Which is stronger?” You choose, then compare another pair. Your choices gradually build a ranking.
That’s the starting point. One decision about two photos feels rather more manageable than deciding what four stars actually means.
Before you choose your best photos, do a rough cull
Before using the tool, give the folder a first pass. Remove failed shots and duplicates from the set you want to compare. With a large batch, that saves rounds spent choosing between photos you already know you won’t use.
You don’t need to settle every difficult choice here. Leave the good candidates in, including the ones you’re unsure about. This first pass just gives you a useful set to work with.
Decide what you’re selecting for, too. A first selection for a client is a different task from updating your portfolio. You might be choosing photos for a submission, an exhibition or a series. Or looking back over the year and trying to decide which photos should stay.
I’d keep that purpose in mind throughout the comparisons.
Two photos, one decision
Drag your photos into the window, or click to select them. Portfolio Selector accepts JPEG, PNG and WebP. It doesn’t accept RAW files, so export JPEGs first if that’s what you’re starting with.
The tool shows two photos next to each other. Click the one you think is better, or use the left and right arrow keys. Then do the same with the next pair.
If you’re unsure, you can skip a pair using the Skip button or the space bar.
You can switch the background between black, gray and white while comparing. Choose whichever background you find easiest to judge against.
You can also add photos along the way. If a photo is already in the selection, the tool skips it and shows a notice. Finding another candidate doesn’t mean you have to start again.
How your choices become a ranking
Behind those pairs is an Elo score, the same rating system used to rank chess players. Every photo starts with the same score. When you choose a photo, its score rises and the other photo’s score drops.
The size of that change depends on the opponent. Beating a highly ranked photo counts for more than beating one with a low score. So the ranking develops through the comparisons, rather than through a score you assign to each photo in isolation.
You don’t have to compare every photo with every other photo. The tool keeps picking a photo that has had relatively few comparisons and pairing it with one on a similar score. The left and right positions are randomized.
You can leave that arithmetic to the tool. Your job is to look at the two photos and choose.
There’s an important limit here: the ranking shows which photos you keep choosing. It doesn’t know what makes a photo good. Those numbers come from your judgment, with a system to put the decisions in order. I wouldn’t give the numbers the final say just because they look tidy.
When to look at the results
A counter shows how many comparisons you’ve made. At roughly three times as many comparisons as photos, the tool tells you that you’ve compared enough to get an initial picture of the ranking.
Treat that as a point to have a look. You can keep going, and more comparisons make the order more reliable. The message doesn’t mean you have to stop or that every position is settled.
The ranking shows all your photos in order, with their scores. The top twenty are highlighted. You can see which photos have kept coming out ahead and which have moved further down the selection.
That gives you somewhere concrete to begin the next decision. For a shoot, look at the leading photos as candidates for your final selection. Keep the purpose you started with in view.
Local, free, and ready when you come back
Portfolio Selector processes your photos in your browser. Nothing is sent to the server. The photos stay on your own device, so dragging them into the window doesn’t upload them somewhere else.
If you close the tab, your session is there when you return on the same device and in the same browser. You can leave a selection and come back to it.
The tool is free, needs no account and is available in Dutch and English.
Premium, part of the paid subscription, lets you save several named selections and open them later, for example “Top 2026”. It also lets you export a PDF contact sheet of the top thirty photos, showing each photo’s rank, file name and score. If you’ve filled in your business details on your account, those appear at the top.
Choose your best photos as a set
Once you have a ranking, look at the leading photos as a group. A portfolio still needs decisions about repetition, sequence and coherence. The highest scores give you candidates. You need to see how those candidates work together.
Check where photos repeat each other. Look at the order. Consider whether a photo belongs in this particular selection, even if it did well in the comparisons.
If you want to present two or three chosen photos together, the diptych and triptych tool is there for that next step. You can also read about showing your work online.
For now, start with a set of photos you want to sort through and a clear idea of what you’re choosing them for. Add them to Portfolio Selector and make the first comparison.